Did
you have a Choice?
The story of the holocaust has a cast of characters as large
as all the religious books "bible's". Comparable to the bible, heroism and evil
are depicted at their limits. Commensurate to the bible, the holocaust ambushes
sensibility in crossfire of human bravery, treachery, and indifference.
Moreover, most people, when asked to define the holocaust, they insinuate only
the fact that six million children, women and men were systematically
obliterated from the earth, for no other reason at all than they were merely
Jews. This verity, staggering as it is, masks the genuine lessons of the
holocaust. It encumbers our imagination, blocking out the human truth of the
holocaust, which abides in the stories of individuals. It is why Ann Frank's
diary is cherished, why stories of the holocaust survivors are so important, or
why justice is demanded when it is discovered that some old man committed
atrocities as young man. If the holocaust becomes as head count, it becomes
nothing. One story that has maintained the holocaust awareness is of John
Demjanjuk, a Ukrainian immigrant who stands accused of having a bloody Nazi
past. As this anecdote grinds on, the true story of the holocaust hero Oskar
Schindler has become the subject of a film described by critics the most
shattering movies ever made on the holocaust. Oskar Schindler and John Demjanuk
exemplify the two different responses to the greatest evil humanity has ever
unleashed upon itself. While there are more villainous than John Demjanuk, and
nobler heroes than Oskar Schindler, they are useful because their stories, when
studied together, embody the greatest lesson the holocaust has to offer.
Demjanuk was an allied soldier, captured by the Nazi, and thrown into a POW
camp. From there, documents have him serving the Nazi in several concentration
camps. Some of his champions, who begrudgingly acknowledge this a possibility,
respond with claim that Demjanuk would not have a Choice, that he would have
been killed if he refused to help murder the Jews. But this assertion is not
supported by history. Numerous records exist of Ukrainian POW's who refused to
work in the death camps. But there is no record of any Ukrainian being killed by
the SS for refusing. Death camp duty was voluntary for POW's unless, of course,
they happened to be Jewish. The claim that one had no Choice has been a rallying
cry not only of active participants in the slaughter, but also those who watched
and did nothing. (The other position made by spectators is that they didn't know
what was happening to their Jewish neighbors and friends. Actor Robert Clary, a
Holocaust survivor, once noted that when he encountered Germans who asserted
ignorance of what was happening; they always affirmed national ignorance, rather
than individual ignorance. "I never met a German who said to me, ' I didn't know
what was happening." They always said, 'WE didn't know.") Oskar Schinler knew.
But this womanizer, black market dealer, and heavy drinker, went down a
different trail. This German Catholic wheeler-dealer ended up spending his
entire fortune and risked Gestapo-style arrest, to save 1200 Jews from certain
death. When the war had ended, Schindler was asked why. His answer is
disturbingly similar to the one often given by the murderers and their
apologists. "There was no Choice." Schindler's claim is the same one made by
most heroes. It is never believed, because it is not true. The hero has a
Choice. Choice is what makes the hero's deeds heroic. It is the Choice that
makes the brute's actions a crime. Without Choice, there could be no heroes or
villains. Those who inquire why the holocaust occurred often question why "God"
would authorize such a cataclysm to take place. If one embraces that our
architect /(s), creator/(s)" endowed humanity with free will, the answer becomes
obvious. "God" did not kill six million Jews. People did. It was people shoved
people into gas chambers. It was people who stood by and allowed their Jewish
neighbors and friends to be hauled away to their deaths. And it was people who
risked their lives to save their fellow human beings from certain death. The
holocaust, equally the bible, teaches that morality cannot exist without freedom
of Choice, and that freedom of Choice demands morals. It is true for the
holocaust hero and the holocaust criminal, and the million of others, who
opposed the evil, but did not. As the holocaust was spawned by Choice, the
holocaust hero, criminal, and spectator seek freedom from Choice, Justice
demands that criminals may not disavow their Choices. Glory demands that heroes
like Oskar Schindler may not repudiate theirs. The majority of people, those who
chose to stand by and do nothing, live in obscurity with their Choice
"decisions". It is the same for most of humanity. The greatest number of the
people is never public heroes or public criminals. But this does not free them
from moral obligation. While the hero's glory and the criminal's scorn are
effortlessly evaded by doing nothing, it is difficult to elude one's own soul.
Genuine heroes and villains will not permit it. If all who stood by had stood
up, there would not have been a holocaust. But they did not stand up, and the
holocaust did happen. The stories of heroes and villains, and the Choices they
make, exist to agonize the souls of those who evade obligation by evading
action, the explanation of the holocaust is a lesson vital to the human race. It
is simple, obvious and universal. While some may be guilty, all are responsible
or just passive conspirators! Cynical accessory!
Raymond Pestalozzi